New Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca wanted some of his own people to join Manchester City when he took over from Pep Guardiola before the 2026/27 season. One of those players was Enzo Fernández. The move was expensive and has not worked out so far.
Maresca managed Fernández at Chelsea, and he was fine in that situation. Chelsea wasn't exactly overperforming, and that might be as much a Maresca issue as a Fernández one, but the problem is that the latter hasn't had nearly the same kind of form with the Blues after joining Man City on September 1 for a £125 million fee.
As harsh as it might seem, Maresca has failed with City, and so has his former Chelsea midfielder. Whatever Maresca thought would work in the midfield hasn't, and that could be due to too much faith in Fernández.
Enzo Fernández hasn't been what Manchester City hoped
The midfielder has left far too much space behind him as he tries to attack, fails, and then realizes he has opened the door for his opponent. He isn't quick to recover because by the time he realizes his mistake, it is far too late.
In eight Premier League matches, the Argentinian has one goal and no assists. He is completing a bunch of his passes, but that hasn't led to any offensive success. In Champions League play, he has been only a bit more successful, with one goal and one assist in four games.
Still, for the amount he cost to acquire, his ability to set up goals versus his inability to stop opponents' success has not been equal. He leaves too much space and too many opportunities for Manchester City's opponents.
Maresca seemingly isn't willing to make any quick changes. He has shown an inability himself, after a red-hot start to the Premier League season and seven straight victories, to make the needed adjustments. Instead, the plan seems to be several things that are all risky.
One is that Erling Haaland will always be able to make his own chances. The Norwegian is one of the best strikers in the world, but even the elite need help.
Another is that wingers Antoine Semenyo and Jeremy Doku will stay healthy and press the opposition, and that hasn't occurred either. Both have dealt with injury concerns, and even their success is based on an extreme.
Yet another is that Enzo Maresca believes his scheme is strong enough to plug-and-play former players he managed into a Manchester City role, and that means the club wins important matches. Enzo Fernández has proven that theory to be incorrect.
The Argentine might be an excellent player, but he might not be a perfect fit with other players. He hasn't done well with City, but the club is stuck with him. Maresca's advice hasn't helped. City has suffered, and part of the issue is Fernández's wretched awareness on the pitch. He could help the rest of the season, but for £125 million, that should never have been a question.
