Skip to main content

4 Manchester City players whose stock is falling at the worst time

Have to be better.
ByLee Vowell
Gianluigi Donnarumma plays for Italy
Gianluigi Donnarumma plays for Italy | JOHN THYS/GettyImages

On the surface, Manchester City's season has looked solid. The club sits in third place on the Premier League table and is still well alive in Champions League play.

But as all Blues fans know, the 2026/27 season feels like two parts: Before the first international break and after the break. Manager Enzo Maresca's club won their first seven PL matches, only to lose their next three. No top-tier club had done that since Sheffield Wednesday in the 1904/05 season.

City returns to league play on November 21 against Fulham. A positive start before the January transfer market is a must; otherwise, changes might be needed. The continued trend of losing could even cost Maresca his job.

These Manchester City players need to be far better after the second international break

Gianluigi Donnarumma

The tall Italian is trending toward his worst season ever. Some of that is because the defense in front of him has been a mess, but Donnarumma has also allowed several easy goals. His ball control in front of the net should make every City fan nervous.

He has allowed 1.3 goals per 90 minutes, the highest mark of his career, and his save percentage is a career low of 65.8 percent. If he is not any better for the rest of the season, he needs to be replaced in 2027/28.

Phil Foden

Foden has been one of the streakiest players for the Blues for a few seasons now, and that hasn't changed in 2026/27. He has played in eight games, started four, and has a goal and a couple of assists. He is often far too easily dispossessed of the ball, though.

Maresca has said he believes in Foden, but his use hasn't proven that. In his last five league appearances, only once has Foden played more than 45 minutes in a match. Three times, he has played 22 minutes or fewer.

Marc Guehi

Before the second international break began, Guehi just looked exceedingly tired. Nine matches in 21 days will do that to a lot of players, but Guehi's form was so poor that he likely should have missed at least one of those matches.

He began the season well, which implies that with a bit of rest (and he isn't playing for England during the break), he might return to form. He hasn't been in position in the midfield, being a big reason for so many recent defensive breakdowns. Hopefully, he is healthy, but we won't know for sure until the club returns.

Nico O'Reilly

O'Reilly has the speed and size to be an elite player, but maybe he is just too young to consistently play at his best. He has had some matches where he has been quite good, but others where he has been -- at best -- invisible.

He isn't being asked to be involved with offensive precision much for some reason, but he is not being used well in Enzo Maresca's alignments. O'Reilly appears lost at times, and in eight Premier League matches has zero goals and zero assists. That needs to change for Manchester City to have a chance to be at the top of the table.

Add us as a preferred source on Google